For a start the data on autophagy isn’t clear and autophagy also isn’t digital ie on or off. Some data show it can take 4 days for autophagy markers to peak. We also see markers associated with anti-autophagy peak on day 3 in one study.
Either way, your one sweet will have no effect on your overall fast, although I’d recommend a better quality of chocolate if you do it again 😉
I always recommend 5 day fasts, either a proper fast (only water) or a FMD of c. 500 calories per day, for those who can’t manage not eating at all for whatever reason. Check out Longo’s work, ideally the primary research articles, but he has simpler articles and videos for the non-scientifically trained.