| | Water Fasting

Can breaks stimulate progress?

A little over 2 weeks ago, I posted about my frustration that weight loss had stalled for me. Right after that, I went on vacation with my family to Disneyland... followed by a few days at the beach. I didn't go crazy, but my IF routine was inconsistent at best. And I had a few bad meals and several beers. When I got home, I expected the worst. What actually happened was that I had "only" gained about 3 lbs... which melted off in ONE DAY. I'm assuming water weight thanks to increased sodium intake. After that, the weight started dropping again like crazy. Now, it has stabilized somewhat... and I'm back to a slow-but-steady crawl toward my goal. All of this is to say that taking a week off and caring a LOT less about being meticulous seems to have actually resulted in getting me even closer to my ultimate goal, rather than setting me back. Has anyone else experienced anything like this? Does a break reset things in some way? Or should I chalk it up to residual effects from all the walking we did around the mouse house? 48M, 6'0"... Started out at 311 lbs.At the time of my "frustration" post, I was 294.8 lbs.As of today, 287 lbs. ​ https://preview.redd.it/0ufag5bttel81.jpg?width=1440&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bf0817a742cb7974a108cf6df076f722c904b79f

Answer

Yeah I had a similar experience after more or less maintaining over the Christmas holidays.

My understanding is this mostly has to do with glycogen rather than some sort of total reset. Glycogen is sugar water stored in our liver and muscles, and it’s another storage of energy for the body besides body fat. The average adult has a couple pounds of it, and most importantly glycogen is one gram of sugar bonded with three grams of water. So unlike fat that’s 3,500 calories per pound, glycogen is something like 1,500 calories for several pounds.

When we are on a deficit, the body prefers to use up the glycogen first - that is its purpose. When the sugar is gone the body lets go of the extra water it doesn’t need. This is part of why folks see dramatic scale results at the beginning of diet changes. The reverse is also true, when we have a surplus the body wants to restock on glycogen and all the water that comes with that.

This is how the scale can spike after a big treat meal despite not eating the thousands of additional calories it would require to add that much body fat. But once we’re back on our deficit we use it up again, water gets let go again.

Answer

It’s a common phenomenon, but idk the exact science behind it. Eating at a deficit is stressful on the body. Stress inhibits weight loss/encourages weight gain. Eating at or above maintenance for a couple days might help lower stress levels and remove the inhibition. I guess it’s kind of like a reset. Personally I feel like I need at least a couple days per month at maintenance.