Hello everyone,
I am a college student who also works part-time in IT so my sleeping and eating patterns are a mess, also I am prediabetic. I have been doing the 20:4 method for a week now, because 16:8 was very similar to the way I have been eating anyway (I rarely ever eat breakfast, 2 meals in a day). The feeling of hunger has been managable (actually I like it), I don't have the shakes I just feel a little weak sometimes but I haven't felt the "mental clarity" or the other benefits people talk about. I don't have a lot of time to workout, I have a set of dumbbells that I lift everyday at home.
* How do I tell if this diet has been working for me? Do I have to eat better (I haven't really changed my diet, though I have reduced the amount of carbs I eat) and work out, or a week is too small a time window to decide? I know that obviously if I work out and eat better it would be more beneficial, I am asking that will I get any benefits from IF even if I don't do these things or should I switch up to an even stricter schedule (I am planning on managing my diet next week when I have time to cook my meals)?
* Can I delay my eating period? For example, I usually eat between 14:00-18:00 then go to sleep shortly after. But yesterday, I was unable to eat until 17:00, leaving just one hour of eating time. Should I have shifted my eating period to 17:00-21:00? Is it important for me to eat at the same time every day, or is it fine if I meet the minimum of 20 hours fast time every day?
* Is it okay if I drink black coffee during fasting? I make my own filtered coffee at home using a filter coffee machine and ground up beans. Is it okay to use flavored coffee beans (peppermint, caramel, chocolate, hazelnut) or should I drink coffee only in my eating time?
Thank you for your suggestions.
Answer
My guess is that you were already experiencing a long period 16 hours of fasting, so moving to 20:4 won’t be that different. (Just in general, I think that some reports of mental clarity have more to do with placebo effect — paying attention to what am you are eating — and partly to avoiding constantly elevated glucose levels.).
It’s hard to answer your question about whether you should change without knowing your your goals — weight loss? Longer time in ketosis?
Answer
Get rid of added sugars and refined carbs. Intermittent fasting works for weight loss because it reduces insulin resistance, not because of calorie deficits. If you’re prediabetic you will experience even more benefits.