| | Water Fasting

Is it supposed to be this easy?

\*\* Deleted and Moved from the New year thread as I have questions\*\* M45 Formerly pretty athletic, bad injury a few years ago and was pretty immobile until a month ago when I had a back procedure . Mainly placated myself though the last two years with food and wine. I've read through all the posts here for months and read several books on the theory. But it always seemed like it would be too difficult. When I weighed into the hospital for my procedure I was 90kg which really didn't sit well with me. I waited till Jan 1st to start officially but had already lost some weight. I'm 84.9 today, I've overshot 16 hours every day so far, usually doing 20 now. I am worried I'm doing something wrong in that I'm always way under 1800 under on my calories and really only eat at 20 because I'm getting pressure to not "starve myself" Questions : Why don't i get hungry…? Am i doing damage by losing weight this quickly? Am i actually starving myself? TL/DR : Lost 5kg / 12 pounds in a month, it seems too easy

Answer

Initial weight loss is typically due to losing water weight as you eat less/healthier. A good portion of that 5kg/12 lbs was probably water weight

EDIT: so for example, say 1-1.5 kg was water weight, which isn’t unheard of, then you are right on track with a healthy weight loss amount per week

Answer

I’m about a week in and lost 4 lbs on 16:8. It seems suspiciously easy to me, too. But I’m just not as hungry, and don’t eat my feelings either. Sometimes, close to the end of my eating window, I wonder if I ate enough, and what else I should eat before the next fast starts. I do expect this to get harder though as time goes on.

Have you restricted certain foods?

Answer

Sounds good to me. I forget to eat some days. Just keep an eye on your nutrition, make sure you’re hitting protein macros and get some good fats in, then be sure to get your micros with a good amount of fruit and veg. Don’t forget it’s a marathon, not a sprint. You need to find something that’s long-term sustainable

Answer

It really depends on the person.

I kinda just fell into IF because it meshes with my natural eating habits. If left to myself I never eat breakfast and rarely eat lunch.

So all I had to do was keep conscious of not nibbling on some piece of my kid’s breakfast as I was making it or not having milk in my coffee and I was pretty much set.

I imagine you’re just more naturally disposed to that sort of eating pattern too.

Answer

By reading a couple of your comments here……remember that having cut your carbs a fair bit, sone of this is water weight.…don’t skimp on protein when fasting in order to save muscle mass…restricted eating is extremely common to reduce hunger. Long story short…it’s one of the main premises. If you are not spiking insulin as often, you are not as hungry….yo over simplify it