| | Water Fasting

"Postabsorptive" vs "fasted?" - conflation in scientific literature?

I've been indulging in a little research on the fasted state recently and I've come across something that's confusing me. A lot of the scientific literature I've been coming across refers to the "postabsorptive state" as the same as the "fasted state" - as in "the postabsorptive, or fasted, state" whereas most guides to IF/fasting seem to imply you go through the fed (absorptive) state, then the postabsorptive state, and THEN into the fasted state. Most guides on fasting state it takes ~12 hours to get into the fasted state, but most descriptions of the absorptive state say it only lasts around 4 hours. The distinction seems to be that in the post-absorptive state food is no longer being digested, but nutrients from the meal are still circulating, which seems like a useful distinction, but then why is the "fasted" state conflated with the "postabsorptive state" in the scientific literature?

Answer

From the limited exposure I have, it seems to be inconsistent terminology. Some treat the postabsorptive state as a transition period between the fed state and the fasted state, but some seem to consider anything after the fed state (absorptive) to be post-absorptive – which, to be fair, is the literal interpretation of the word.

Answer

Once food has been ingested, it has to be digested, and then the nutrients must be absorbed into the blood stream. That can take up to 4 hrs for most people. So, “postabsorptive” refers to the time after “active” absorption. In this sense, the term is synonymous with “fasted.” However, in practice, when people talk about fasting, it usually refers to the period beginning after the last meal was completed, which could include the absorptive phase. That’s why hormonal changes associated with fasting occur within a time-range. For all practical purposes, it doesn’t matter. The literature uses more specific terminology as part of research: answering questions, collecting and analysing data, interpreting results to plan or inform next steps.