While I agree to a certain extent, I disagree with the carbs part. I’ve done this and still eat carbs (albeit, under 100g) and have not gained anything back. Just don’t eat crappy, there’s no reason to cut out food groups.
You regained the weight back and more because you went straight to your shit eating habits (Overeating) not because you ate carbs again. One can use snake juice to drop the amount of pounds they want and then stop fasting and still not regain anything as long as they don’t overeat, this is why cole said that if you regain everytime you refeed then you need to stop putting everything in your mouth like you are a beer about to hibernate
The only answer for any addict is for them to want to change enough to actually change. There are plenty of addicts who know they need to change but they don’t want it enough. People can yo-yo an any diet that includes the fundamentals of cutting back on sugar, highly processed foods, and calorie restriction. Even if an addict does want the change, they’re still going to spend years undoing the damage to their neural pathways and will have setbacks. This is the case for any addict no matter what system they subscribe to. I don’t think there’s one person in this sub who hasn’t fallen down on a fasting-focused lifestyle on occasions.
I beleive that Cole’s diets is powerful but also completely Unnecessar. I had done it for a while and ended up blimic. If the goal is like you said to lose weight forever than just do it the regular way ie. work out, eat healthy, dont eat too much. Mix in some 24s every couple weeks. Like you said, If you want real results, change your lifestyle. But that lifestyle doesent have to be a fasting lifestyle. Huamns aren’t carnivores we should be eating multiple times a day. Eat healthy, workout (ie. resistance trainin) focus on putting on muscle not just burning calories or “losing fat”. BUT MOST OF ALL, your goal should be to be health, not look “sexy”. If you focus on being “healthy” the aesthetic results will come.
Only thing I can say is if you lose 35lbs in 10 days you are overweight to begin with surely. No healthy human will be throwing off bodyweight like that. You probably return to your obese eating habits. Just try to keep eating lean
One thing to look into is your body’s weight anchor bias. After a certain time at a specific weight your body re-calibrates to thinking you should be that weight. That’s why the yo-yo happens. If you make it your lifestyle however, the re-calibration is at your lean weight because you’ve keep the fat off for a long enough period.
I’ve maintained for a few years doing OMAD, plus some cheat on the weekends. I’m going to start doing Dry OMADs now (Skeleton Diet) after basically doing my current 5 day fast but being as dry as possible (dying for water at night).